Holidays & Gatherings > Gifts
The 15 Most Popular Baseball Gifts For Christmas 2025
From top-tested items to editor favorites & expert mom opinions, these are the hottest baseball gifts you can buy.
By Stephanie Ryder Updated: Oct. 24, 2025
Here at Baseball Gift Guide, we know that finding the perfect gift for the baseball lover in your life is time-consuming work. That's why our editors regularly scour the internet to find the newest, coolest, and absolute must haves for any serious baseball fan.
This guide has a little bit of everything for everyone in it. From custom barware made out of hardwood, to the coolest incognito screen protector, to one of the most fun and nostalgic games we've played in a long time.
We know budgets vary too, so we wanted to make sure we include price ranges for all, so everyone can have a holly jolly good gifting experience this gifting season, enjoy!
1. The Original Dugout Mug
Why We Picked It: The original Dugout Mug tops our list because it turns an actual baseball bat barrel into a one-of-a-kind drinking mug that feels authentic to the game itself.
It’s handcrafted in the USA and officially licensed by Major League Baseball, making it a collectible with real character.
Few gifts capture the spirit of baseball quite like sipping your favorite drink straight from the wood of the game.
2. Baseball Board Game
Why We Picked It: Crafted from high-quality materials with a maple-wood veneer and durable pegs, this game blends vintage design with simple mechanics, making it perfect for family game nights.
The dice-driven advances around bases offer charm, nostalgia and easy replay value. It stands out as a gift that looks as good on display as it does in play.
3. Sandlot "Legends Never Die" Hat
3. Sandlot
"Legends Never Die" Hat
Why We Picked It: The “Legends Never Die” Cork Hat stands out because it blends baseball culture with high-end craftsmanship: real cork face, custom printed bill, puff embroidery, and a waterproof polyester/mesh build.
It’s exclusive and limited (only 1,000 pieces) which makes it feel more like a collector’s piece than a regular cap.
The hat pays tribute to the classic film The Sandlot through a collaboration with its writer/director, giving it a resonant story that any true baseball fan will appreciate.
4. Savannah Bananas Swag
Why We Picked It: The Savannah Bananas Collection made our list because it captures the joyful chaos that has made the Bananas a national sensation.
Every item, from bat mugs to bottle openers, carries that same fun-loving energy that baseball fans adore.
It is playful, bold, and impossible not to smile at, making it a perfect gift for anyone who loves the lighter side of the game.
5. Baseball BBQ Access.
Why We Picked It: The Baseball BBQ collection brings baseball fandom into the backyard with tools and gear clearly inspired by the game.
From team-branded spatulas and tongs to combo sets that make the grill feel like home plate, every piece blends function with fan pride.
It’s the kind of gift that turns a cook-out into a ballgame experience for any fan in attendance.
6. Custom Photo Baseball Bat Mugs
6. Custom Photo
Baseball Bat Mugs
Why We Picked It: The Custom Photo Mug stands out because you can personalize it with your own photo laser-etched onto a real birch-wood baseball bat barrel turned into a functional one-of-a-kind mug.
The fusion of personal memory and authentic baseball gear creates a gift that is both deeply meaningful and unmistakably connected to the sport.
It ticks the box for “custom keepsake that actually gets used” in a way many typical fan gifts don’t.
7. Screen Skinz
Why We Picked It: The “Screen Skinz” privacy screen protector combines everyday function with team spirit in a subtle, high-quality way.
The MLB logo appears only when the screen is off, disappearing when the device is in use, giving it a sleek and clever touch.
It is perfect for fans who want to show their loyalty without compromising style or phone protection.
8. MLB Laser Etched Wood Coasters
8. MLB Laser Etched
Wood Coasters
Why We Picked It: The MLB Wooden Coaster Collection offers fans stylish, game-day ready décor that works on the coffee table as easily as the tailgate.
Each coaster carries official team branding on a birch wood surface so you’re celebrating team loyalty with subtle class.
It’s an affordable gift that blends function and fandom effortlessly.
9. Plate Crate
Why We Picked It: The Plate Crate subscription box highlights a gift idea that keeps giving every month.
Perfect for baseball fans who live and breathe the sport.
Each box includes gear, training aids, apparel, and fun baseball-themed items that cater especially to active players or dedicated fans.
It stands out as a versatile present that goes beyond a one-time gift and brings consistent value and excitement.
10. The Cutter - Baseball Bottle Opener
10. The Cutter
Baseball Bottle Opener
Why We Picked It: The “Cutter” bottle opener is crafted from a real baseball cut in half, creating a bold, tactile reminder of the sport every time you pop a cap.
With licensed MLB logos printed directly on the wood, it brings serious fan cred to the tailgate or home bar.
It’s a standout gift for baseball fans who appreciate gear that’s as functional as it is authentic.
11. Baseball Seam Earrings
Why We Picked It: The baseball seam earrings are crafted using real used baseballs which gives each pair a unique story and connection to the sport.
The lightweight stainless-steel setting keeps them wearable and sleek while letting the faded seams provide raw field-wear character.
They’re a stylish, subtle nod to baseball fandom that works both on and off the field.
12. Baseball Bags
Why We Picked It: The baseball drawstring bag stands out because it captures the look and feel of a real baseball while still being practical for everyday use.
It is roomy enough for clothes, water bottles, or a glove, making it great for the gym or travel.
There is also a softball version available, making it a fun and versatile gift for fans of both sports.
13. MLB Season Openers
Why We Picked It: The Season Opener is that it's a clever and game-day worthy gift because it transforms a real baseball bat handle into a durable bottle opener that fans will actually use.
Crafted from real wood and metal, it celebrates your favorite team while clicking open a cold one in style.
With over 30 MLB team logos in the collection, it offers a personalized touch for any fan’s man-cave or tailgate setup.
14. The BrewBox
Why We Picked It: The BrewBox is a practical and creative gift that doubles as both a drink cooler and an insulated lunch box.
It keeps beverages cold for up to 24 hours thanks to its four layers of insulation, making it perfect for tailgates, beach days, or game nights.
With official team logos, it combines everyday function with fan pride in one clean design.
15. 3D Baseball Dad Decor / Ornament
15. 3D Baseball
Dad Decor / Ornament
Why We Picked It: The new Baseball Dad 3D Layered Wood Art and Ornament capture the bond between fathers and the game in a heartfelt and timeless way.
Each piece features layered wood artwork that shows iconic baseball moments like playing catch and celebrating together.
Made in the USA with precision craftsmanship, they make meaningful gifts that remind every dad why baseball is more than just a game.